SAME-SEX MARRIAGE WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE BRAZILIAN SUPREME COURT: Legal Reasoning additionally the danger of a Regressive Turn 1

SAME-SEX MARRIAGE WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE BRAZILIAN SUPREME COURT: Legal Reasoning additionally the danger of a Regressive Turn 1

Casamento homoafetivo no Supremo Tribunal Federal: argumentacao juridica e o risco de retrocesso

* Fundacao Getulio Vargas, Sao Paulo, SP, Brasil. Email: flavia. Puschel@fgv.br

This paper investigates what lengths the Brazilian Supreme Court has argumentatively committed it self to upholding same-sex wedding in the facial skin of potential restrictive legislation in line with the reasoning the court found in its 2011 ruling about same-sex domestic partnerships. The paper concludes that the separation of litigation over domestic partnerships and wedding might have generated the possibility of a turn that is regressive homosexual legal rights with this matter.

KEYWORD PHRASES: same-sex wedding; same-sex domestic partnership; Brazilian Supreme Court; appropriate thinking; separation of abilities

https://www.camsloveaholics.com/camonster-review

Este artigo pretende estabelecer em que medida o STF comprometeu-se argumentativamente a sustentar a inconstitucionalidade de possivel legislacao restritiva ao casamento entre pessoas do mesmo sexo, com base nos argumentos que fundamentaram sua decisao sobre uniao estavel homoafetiva. Conclui-se que a da that is separacao sobre uniao estavel e casamento pode ter resultado em risco de retrocesso em relacao aos direitos das pessoas homossexuais.

PALAVRAS-CHAVE: casamento homoafetivo; uniao estavel homoafetiva; Supremo Tribunal Federal; argumentacao juridica; separacao de poderes

The battle that is social same-sex wedding in Brazil played call at the Judiciary and had been achieved through one ruling because of the Supreme Court (Supremo Tribunal Federal – STF), one ruling because of the Superior Court of Justice (Superior Tribunal de Justica – STJ), 2 both from 2011, and something administrative act by the National Justice Council (Conselho Nacional de Justica – CNJ), in 2013. 3

Continue reading “SAME-SEX MARRIAGE WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE BRAZILIAN SUPREME COURT: Legal Reasoning additionally the danger of a Regressive Turn 1”